Hiring & Cost

10 Questions to Ask an SEO Agency Before You Sign the Contract

Most SEO contracts in India get signed after one good sales call. The person on that call is senior, sharp and convincing. Then the work starts, your account goes to someone you've never met, and you find a long lock-in clause on page four. These are the 10 questions to ask an SEO agency before you sign anything. For each one, I'll tell you what a good answer sounds like and the red flag to listen for.

Why this matters for your business

Take a ₹40,000 a month retainer on a 12-month contract. That's ₹4.8 lakh committed, plus GST, before you know whether it works. The fee isn't even the biggest risk.

The bigger risks are time and damage. SEO takes months to show results, so a wrong hire can cost you most of a year. A bad agency can also leave you worse off: spammy links that hold your site back, AI-written pages nobody reads, and accounts you don't own when you try to leave.

Ten good questions take thirty minutes on a call. That's the cheapest insurance you'll buy this year. If you're still shortlisting, start with my guide on what to look for in an SEO company in India, then use the questions below on your final two or three.

The 10 questions to ask an SEO agency before you sign

Ask these on the call, and ask for the important ones in writing. A good agency will answer most of them without being asked.

1. Who exactly will work on my account, and can I meet them?

In many agencies, the founder sells and a junior executive delivers. That's not always bad, but you should know before you pay.

Good answer: names, roles and experience of the people doing the work, and an offer to put them on the next call.

Red flag: "Our team of experts will handle it." If they won't name the person, assume it's someone in their first year.

2. Will my Search Console, Analytics, Business Profile and content be in my name?

Google Search Console is the free tool where Google shows how your site performs in search. Google Analytics shows what visitors do once they arrive. Together they hold your site's history.

Good answer: "You create the accounts with your company login and give us access." The same goes for your Google Business Profile, domain, hosting and every page they write.

Red flag: the agency sets everything up under its own login "to keep it simple." That makes leaving very painful.

3. How long is the lock-in, and what's the notice period?

Some agencies ask for 6 or 12 months upfront. Their reason is that SEO takes time, which is true. But patience is something you choose. A lock-in is something you're forced into.

Good answer: month to month, or a short first term with a 30-day notice period, written into the contract. For what it's worth, our own retainer has a 6-month minimum, stated before you sign.

Red flag: a long lock-in with no exit clause, or a penalty for leaving early even when targets are missed.

The contract length also depends on how the work is priced. If one quote is a retainer and another is "pay only when you rank", read my guide on how monthly, project and performance-based SEO deals differ before you compare terms.

4. How will you report leads and revenue?

Rankings and traffic are easy to make look good. Enquiries are not.

Good answer: a monthly report that starts with leads or sales from organic search, compared with the same month last year, then shows traffic to your money pages. Ask for a sample. Here's what a useful monthly SEO report looks like so you can compare.

Red flag: the headline numbers are "keywords ranked," impressions and backlink counts, with no lead figure anywhere.

5. What will you do in the first 90 days?

The first three months tell you whether the agency has a plan or a template.

Good answer: an audit first, then fixes ranked by their effect on leads, then work on your most important service or product pages. If you haven't had one, read about the audit that should come before any monthly work.

Red flag: "20 blog posts and 100 backlinks a month" before anyone has looked at your site.

6. What results do you expect, and by when?

This is one of the questions Google itself suggests asking any SEO, along with how they measure success.

Good answer: a range, tied to your business type and starting point, with early signs to look for in months two to four. It should match honest SEO timelines by business type.

Red flag: "Page one in 30 days," or any ranking guarantee. Google says plainly that no one can guarantee a number one ranking.

Links from other websites still matter. How they're earned matters more. Google's spam policies treat links created mainly to manipulate rankings as link spam, and that includes buying links that pass ranking credit.

Good answer: a small number of real links from relevant sites, earned through useful content, PR, partners or directories that actually matter in your industry. You see every link, with the site name.

Red flag: monthly packages of hundreds of links, or "guest posts" on sites that exist only to sell posts.

8. Can you show me results I can verify?

Every agency has case studies. Not every case study has proof.

Good answer: a named client, a clear time period, and numbers from a source you recognise, like Search Console or Analytics. Ask whether you can speak to that client.

Red flag: "We grew traffic by 500%" with no client name, no dates and no screenshot.

9. Will you share every change you make to my site, and why?

Google suggests asking this too. You're responsible for what anyone does to your site in your name.

Good answer: a change log with the page, the change and the reason. If they use AI to draft content, they should tell you and check every fact before it goes live.

Red flag: "We'll need full admin access" with no explanation of what they'll do with it.

10. What happens to my site and data if we stop working together?

This is the question nobody asks, and the one that matters most on the day you leave.

Good answer: a written handover. You keep all accounts, content, reports, keyword research and tracking setups. Access is removed cleanly within a few days.

Red flag: content "licensed" to you only while you pay, or reports and data that stay with the agency.

Before you sign: a 2-minute contract check

Read the contract with these lines in mind. Tick each one that's true:

  • The people doing the work are named, or at least their roles are
  • All accounts and content are owned by your company
  • The term and notice period are written down, with no penalty for leaving after notice
  • The monthly deliverables are listed
  • Leads or sales from organic search are part of the reporting
  • The price says whether GST is included
  • There's a handover clause for when the contract ends

Five or more ticks is a solid contract. Fewer than four, ask for changes before you sign. A good agency won't mind.

Myth vs fact
Myth

A long contract means the agency is committed to my results.

Fact

A long contract commits you, not them. An agency confident in its work is happy to earn your business month by month.

Myth

The bigger the agency, the safer the choice.

Fact

Size tells you little about who works on your account. A small team led by a senior person can beat a large agency where juniors handle smaller clients.

Myth

If they guarantee page one, they must know something others don't.

Fact

Google says no one can guarantee a number one ranking. Guarantees usually mean shortcuts, or rankings for search terms nobody types.

Myth

Asking hard questions will put a good agency off.

Fact

Good agencies like these questions because they have good answers. The ones who get defensive are the ones you want to find out about early.

What changed recently
  • Google's September 2026 spam update finished rolling out on 8 October, after starting on 24 September. If you're comparing agencies right now, question 7 matters more than usual. Ask how their link building would hold up against Google's spam policies. Source: Google Search Status Dashboard
  • Google updated its guidance on using generative AI content. It warns that generating many pages without adding value can break its scaled content abuse policy, and that AI output should be fact-checked before publishing. Ask any agency how much of its content is AI-written and who checks it. Source: Google Search Central

When to get help

You can run these questions yourself. Print them, take them into your next two or three agency calls, and compare the answers side by side. That alone will rule out most bad fits.

Get a second opinion when two agencies give you very different plans for the same site, when a proposal is full of deliverables but says nothing about leads, or when you're about to sign a long contract and want someone to read it first. Send me the proposal and your site, and I'll tell you what I'd ask them to change. There are more guides for founders choosing SEO help on the blog.

Frequently asked questions

What should I ask an SEO company before hiring them?

Ask who will do the work, who owns your accounts and content, how long the contract runs, how you can exit, how leads will be reported, what happens in the first 90 days, how links are built, and for results you can verify. Also ask what results they expect and by when. Clear, specific answers matter more than a polished pitch.

Is a 12-month SEO contract normal in India?

It's common, but you shouldn't need one to get good work. SEO takes months, so a sensible agency will ask for patience, not a legal lock-in. A month-to-month plan, or a short first term with a 30-day notice period, is fairer. If an agency insists on 12 months upfront, ask what you get in return for that commitment.

Who should own my Google Search Console and Analytics accounts?

You should. Create the accounts under your company's own Google login and give the agency user access. The same goes for Google Business Profile, your domain, hosting and any content they write. If the agency owns these, leaving them means losing your data and history, which makes it very hard to switch.

Can an SEO agency guarantee first page rankings?

No. Google states plainly that no one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google. An agency can promise the work it will do, how often it will report, and the business goals it will track. A ranking guarantee is usually a sign of cheap tricks, or of ranking you for search terms nobody uses.

What are the red flags when hiring an SEO agency?

Ranking guarantees, long lock-ins with no exit clause, agency-owned accounts, vague answers about who does the work, link packages sold by the hundred, and reports that show traffic but never leads. Another red flag is case studies with no client name, no date range and no source. Proof you can't check isn't proof.

Related reading

Browse every guide on the SERP EDGE blog.